View Single Post
Old 08-06-2007, 04:33 PM   #10 (permalink)
garysher
Partisan
Premium Member
 
garysher's Avatar
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Los Angeles
Gender: Male
Posts: 9,641
Country:
Points: 29,811, Level: 99
Points: 29,811, Level: 99 Points: 29,811, Level: 99 Points: 29,811, Level: 99
Level up: 89%, 189 Points needed
Level up: 89% Level up: 89% Level up: 89%
Activity: 100%
Activity: 100% Activity: 100% Activity: 100%
garysher is offline
Reply With Quote
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Jaxian View Post
I believe you are saying that religion leads only a small minority of people to commit evil acts. I disagree. When I talk about evil acts, I am not talking only about murder, but about any action which harms another person for no reason.

The easiest example of what I'm talking about is political issues. Any person who votes in favor of putting the ten commandments up in our courts, for example, is committing an evil act. Anyone who opposes stem cell research is committing an evil act. Any person who opposes gay marriage is committing an evil act. All of these things hurt people for no reason, and so they are evil. But so many people do these things that it is almost unthinkable. These widespread evils are most often committed for religious reasons.

I suspect you are religious, so perhaps you will disagree with me about these issues. If so, then I can show you what I mean by looking at older times. In the World's history, religious beliefs have been the primary justification for war and genocide. Religious beliefs have justified inquisitions, where atheists and people of other religions were murdered and deported. Religious beliefs brought us the idea of manifest destiny, which led Americans to massacre Native Americans. These evils are rooted in following a moral system other than kindness toward others.
Hey Jax, I think you are expressing a very vague notion of what is evil and what is kindness!

I think you are grossly undervaluing the concept of evil. Putting up the 10 Commandments in a court isn't evil! No more than putting up verses from the Quoran.

I agree you may not want the legal system to be based on either, but that doesn't make it evil.

And basing an entire moral system on kindness towards others may be cute, but it's wide open to interpretation and therefore wholly inadequate.

If you are a parent you will know that sometimes you have to discipline children to show kindness. One person's kindness is another person's punishment.

And I fail to see why opposing gay marriage is evil. Do you feel the same way about opposing polygamy, or incestuous marriage?

You also omit any mention of all the great acts of kindness which are carried out in the name of religion from time immemorial.

Not to mention the billions of lives that have been blessed and given purpose through a religious faith.