Why am I equating castration of any kind to killing??!

I didn't know that I was!!!

I think maybe you should re-read what I said! If a man has a problem controlling himself, then maybe the answer is removal of the offending member. This is a VERY old form of Justice, currently in use in the Islamic world, but historically found all over.

I was stating, in my own way, that maybe the answer is to go back to an older style of punishment.